55% of the respondents aged between 18 and 25 who smoke waterpipe (shisha, narghile, etc.) tobacco do so daily or once a week. (Photo: Martin Büdenbender / Pixabay)
A study led by the UOC spinoff Open Evidence examines consumer behaviour and perceptions of tobacco products in Europe
55% of the respondents aged between 18 and 25 who smoke waterpipe (shisha,narghile, etc..) tobacco do so daily or once a week
90% of electronic cigarette smokers also consume conventional cigarettes
Social media are becoming a channel for covert and indirect advertising for emerging tobacco products
A study led by the UOC spinoff Open Evidence has analysed the preferences and perceptions of consumers in nine EU countries and the United Kingdom as regards five tobacco products: conventional cigarettes, slim cigarettes, small cigarillos, electronic cigarettes and heated tobacco products (HTP). The main results of the research show that, among the respondents, Spain is one of the European countries with the most young people aged between 18 and 25 years old who are waterpipe (sisha, narguile, etc.) smokers. It also confirms that consumption of some products overlaps: 90% of electronic cigarette smokers also consume conventional cigarettes. It warns how social media are becoming a channel for the covert and indirect promotion of tobacco products prohibited by the European Tobacco Products Directive (TPD) in several countries.
The study, in which researchers from the London School of Economics (LSE), the Catalan Institute of Oncology (ICO) and the company BDI Research also participated, provides information to enable the European Union to identify market trends and thereby be able to update possible tobacco control policies, with the ultimate goal of protecting public health. "The study aims to gather evidence on new trends in the tobacco market and about new and emerging products, about which we still do not have much information," explains the UOC researcher and professor and founding partner of Open Evidence, Francisco Lupiáñez, who led the project.
In addition to performing a systematic review of the literature and analysing the existing data, the study conducted an online survey of 12,000 people. The member states of Spain, Bulgaria, France, Germany, Greece, Italy, Latvia, Poland and Slovakia, as well as the United Kingdom, were surveyed to ensure adequate geographical coverage. Each country provided two samples. The first sample contained 600 smokers and people who had given up smoking in the previous 12 months, aged 26 years old or over. The second sample consisted of 600 people aged between 18 and 25 years old. Focus group discussions also took place in five member states (Spain, Germany, France, Bulgaria and Greece) to gather qualitative information on current trends.
The main conclusions of the study are as follows:
- Slim cigarettes are slightly more widely used by women (accounting for 58% of consumers aged 18 to 25), while small cigarillos are mainly consumed by men (70% of consumers aged 18 to 25 are male). As for consumption of waterpipe tobacco, 62% of users are men. The consumption of the other products analysed is relatively equal in terms of gender.
- As regards the perception of the various products, the participants in the focus groups - especially those in the eastern member states - associate slim cigarettes with femininity and business environments, while they associate masculinity with small cigarillos.
- The main reasons for starting to consume tobacco products are for fun, because of feeling stressed, and the belief that smoking can help with relaxation, for socialization and to be fashionable. One of the reasons why users choose certain products is because they believe that they are less harmful to their health, even when there is no evidence of that. For example, some consumers of slim cigarettes sometimes needed to consume more of those cigarettes to feel as satisfied than they would by smoking conventional cigarettes.
- Heated tobacco products and electronic cigarettes are seen as consumption experiences that are colder, more modern and technological, and lack the sense of satisfaction that conventional cigarettes provide. Slim cigarettes and small cigarillos are generally perceived as old-fashioned (e.g. authentic, oriented towards gender, etc.). The participants usually dissociated waterpipe tobacco from other tobacco and related products, as it is consumed in specific environments and in groups.
- Electronic cigarette smokers are primarily dual consumers. More than 7 out of 10 young people between the ages of 18 and 25, and 8 out of 10 people aged 26 and over who consume electronic cigarettes are dual smokers: they also smoke other tobacco products, and mainly conventional cigarettes. 1 in 4 young people between the ages of 18 and 25 and 3 in 10 had only smoked electronic cigarettes in the past, and now consume other tobacco products: 90% of the respondents also smoke conventional cigarettes as well as electronic cigarettes. "These data suggest that the use of electronic cigarettes does not have an impact in terms of reducing the consumption of conventional tobacco," says the UOC researcher and professor.
- Smokers of Heated Tobacco Products (HTP) consume between 1 and 10 sticks a day. People consume this product for the first time because of reasons related to enjoyment or a desire to give up or cut down on conventional tobacco products. Approximately 85% of HTP smokers are dual smokers. Approximately 75% of the respondents agree that HTP should be regulated in the same way as conventional cigarettes, and that there should be many more restrictions on their use in the workplace, on public transport and in the hospitality sector.
- As for the perception of the risk of smoking each product on the market, conventional cigarettes are considered the most harmful. Young people aged between 18 and 25 years old consider HTP to be 35% less harmful than conventional cigarettes, and 46% think they are less harmful for non-smokers. People aged 26 and over believe these products are 46% less harmful to smokers, and 58% less harmful to non-smokers.
20% of waterpipe tobacco smokers aged between 18 and 25 consume the product daily
With its review of the scientific literature, the study highlights how most previous research has shown that young people, and especially men (62% of the respondents), find waterpipe tobacco (shishas, hookahs, etc.) particularly appealing due to the wide range of flavours available. These studies show how users of this product are exposed to many of the toxic compounds and by-products which users of conventional cigarettes are also exposed to.
The online survey identified high levels of waterpipe tobacco consumption in the group aged 18 to 25 years old. Over half the respondents who consume this product (53%) have consumed it at least once or twice. Spain is one of the countries studied which has a particularly high waterpipe tobacco consumption rate, together with Bulgaria and Greece. One-fifth (19%) of the Spaniards surveyed in the 18 to 25 age group are consumers.
In this age group, one-fifth of current users (20%) report using the product on a daily basis, and 35% use it weekly. Although there are fewer users in the group aged 26 or older, those who smoke seem to do so more often: a quarter (25%) consume waterpipe tobacco daily, and almost two-fifths (37%) do so weekly.
33% of the daily smokers surveyed aged between 18 and 25 years spend between 5-15 minutes a day smoking; 27% spend between 16 and 30 minutes; 22% spend between 31 and 60 minutes, 8% spend between 61 and 90 minutes, and 9% spend more than 90 minutes.
Furthermore, the study shows how waterpipe tobacco is usually dissociated from other tobacco and related products, as it is used on special premises and in groups. "This is worrying, as it may limit users' exposure to the health warnings that are found on conventional cigarette packs, for example," explains Lupiáñez.
Social media - a channel for covert or indirect promotion
Emerging products such as HTP pose a challenge to the application of prohibitions and restrictions on advertising, promotion and sponsorship. According to the study, these devices are marketed in various member states by projecting a healthier product image than the other products, and of normalized tobacco product use. "The challenges arise in particular from the growing use of the internet and social media for indirect or covert advertising. The industry increasingly appears to be using these channels to take advantage of legal loopholes and circumvent bans," says the co-founder of Open Evidence.
Social media contain content generated by consumers themselves which can influence public opinion and perception, and this carries a risk of smoking in public becoming normalized once again. Most of the respondents expressed their concern at the influence of the marketing and designs that HTP use to attract young people. "Previous studies have shown that making the design of these products uniform reduces the product's appeal to adolescents," explains the UOC expert.
Current research concludes that none of the tobacco products studied are free of health risks. Studies provide no evidence that slim cigarettes, small cigarillos, waterpipe tobacco or HTPs should be considered less harmful than conventional cigarettes. Lupiáñez believes this is a concern because users of these products think they are "safer" than conventional ones.
The UOC's research and innovation (R&I) is helping overcome pressing challenges faced by global societies in the 21st century, by studying interactions between technology and human & social sciences with a specific focus on the network society, e-learning and e-health. Over 500 researchers and 51 research groups work among the University's seven faculties and two research centres: the Internet Interdisciplinary Institute (IN3) and the eHealth Center (eHC).
The United Nations' 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development and open knowledge serve as strategic pillars for the UOC's teaching, research and innovation. More information: research.uoc.edu. #UOC25years