Current events

UOC selected as case study for globally redefining scientific assessment

  library

Susan Yin / unsplash.com

The organization responsible for the San Francisco Declaration will showcase 11 institutions from around the world who stand out for their initiative to foster quality-based academic knowledge assessment

The UOC is one of 11 academic institutions from around the world selected as inspiring case studies of a new global method for assessing research. The initiative, titled Reimagining academic assessment: stories of innovation and change, is coordinated by the organizers of the San Francisco Declaration on Research Assessment (DORA), together with the European University Association (EUA) and SPARC Europe, an organization focused on bringing knowledge into open access.

According to Vice President for Strategic Planning and Research Marta Aymerich, the fact that DORA selected the UOC as one of its case studies comes as "a boost of legitimacy to keep working on a new way of assessing research that downplays journals' impact factor and emphasizes the actual research content instead, including its impact for society". She added: "Moving towards more apposite assessment gives you the feeling that you're contributing to fairer and more transparent assessment, and it connects you to society, allowing you to step down from the proverbial ivory tower atop which we academics are sometimes perched."

The UOC's journey began in January 2019, when it became the first university in Spain to sign the DORA, which has thus far garnered support from over 2,100 academic organizations worldwide. DORA was drafted by a group of academic journal editors gathered at the American Society for Cell Biology's annual meeting in San Francisco in 2012. Its main proponents underscored the need to update the current impact factor-centred research assessment system, maintaining that the value of scientific activity should be based on its quality, not the notoriety of the scientific journals in which it is featured. 

 

UOC changes help to transform the system

The UOC joined the initiative by rolling out its Open Knowledge Action Plan. According to UOC Vice President for Globalization and Cooperation Pastora Martnez Samper, "We see open knowledge as a key factor in addressing the global challenges that we face as a society, which are laid out in the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development". The Vice President went on to say that the University signed the DORA manifesto to "reaffirm our commitment to transforming research assessment to make it more qualitative, transparent, fair and inclusive. It's a matter of going back to thinking of assessment as a way of improving the research we do, rather than of inspecting or controlling it". Marta Aymerich also highlighted the University's commitment in this respect, saying, "we want to drive change in our University that encourages transformation of the research assessment system around us".

 

New open knowledge policy in the works

In addition to signing the manifesto, the UOC has taken an active role in numerous international forums, at which it has advocated for a paradigm shift in the way research is assessed. Being selected as one of the DORA case studies is an opportunity to "showcase our change process on the global stage," said Nadja Gmelch, director of Open Knowledge Projects. 

A case in point is the University's new open knowledge policy, which is set to be drafted in 2021. To get the ball rolling, an internal participatory process was launched during International Open Access Week last autumn, for the new policy. This challenge joins the other key initiatives under way at the University to promote open knowledge. The data produced in UOC research, for instance, is made available following the FAIR principles, according to which data should be findable, accessible, interoperable and reusable. 

Gmelch said: "The crisis triggered by the pandemic has highlighted the need to share knowledge as openly and seamlessly as possible." One great example of this is the Emergency Remote Teaching project launched by the UOC last April, to share its knowledge with university and institute faculty around the world via webinars and MOOCs.

The push for open knowledge is aligned with the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) to improve people's lives, protect the planet and ensure global prosperity. 

UOC R&I

The UOC's research and innovation (R&I) are helping 21st-century global societies to overcome pressing challenges by studying the interactions between ICT and human activity, with a specific focus on e-learning and e-health. Over 400 researchers and 50 research groups work among the University's seven faculties and two research centres: the Internet Interdisciplinary Institute (IN3) and the eHealth Center (eHC).

The United Nations' 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development and open knowledge serve as strategic pillars for the UOC's teaching, research and innovation. More information:research.uoc.edu#UOC25years

#UOCexperts

Photograph of Marta Aymerich Martnez

Marta Aymerich Martnez

Vice President for Strategic Planning and Research

Expert in: Translating research findings into clinical and/or public health practice; evaluating research.

Knowledge area: Public health and research policy.

View file
Photograph of Pastora Martnez

Pastora Martnez Samper

Vice President for Globalization and Cooperation

Expert in: Management and assessment of research, responsible research and innovation, and open science.

Knowledge area: Political science.

View file

Nadja Gmelch

Director of Open Knowledge Projects

Expert in:

Knowledge area: Political science.