Digitization represents a key solution to the challenges of higher education institutions and for students with special needs. (Foto de Sergey Zolkin, Unsplash)
More than 250 participants in the study recognized the specific benefits provided by e-authentication but expressed concerns about the risk of technical problems
Researchers identify three key influential factors in terms of willingness to use the system: the level of technical know-how, the additional effort required to use the system and the degree to which they deem the technology to be intrusive
While the digitization process offers an extensive list of opportunities, it also presents a number of challenges for higher education institutions, a primary one of which is learner authentication in online education. More and more higher education establishments are making use of digital learning environments (DLE), and electronic assessment systems are now an increasingly important element in the digital age, both for academic institutions and for students, including those with special educational needs and disabilities (SEND).
David Bañeres is a researcher with the IN3 SOM Research Lab group and professor at the Faculty of Computer Science, Multimedia and Telecommunications at Universitat Oberta de Catalunya (UOC). He recently published a study in the ETHE open access journal, that he conducted in conjunction with researchers from Finland, Turkey and the United Kingdom to evaluate the needs of this faction of the student community. "The study was developed as a result of one of the advantages provided by the UOC's TeSLA system (an adaptive trust-based e-assessment learning authentication system), which facilitates access to online assessment for students with disabilities."
The researchers analysed the perceptions and views of students representing this group that attend those universities that have participated in the European TeSLA project: the University of Jyväskylä (Finland), the Open University (UK) and Anadolu University (Turkey). As Bañeres explained: "We evaluated the perceptions of students with special educational needs and disabilities in relation to the use of an authentication and authorship validation system and the sharing of personal biometric data, which, for some students, may include highly sensitive information related to their special need or disability."
The study was carried out within the framework of legislation related to online education and online services. New legislation has been introduced in the EU regarding privacy and data transfer (General Data Protection Regulation, GDPR) and accessibility (Directive [EU] 2016/2102), which has led to an increased awareness of these issues among end users (European Commission, 2016; Voigt and Bussche, 2017).
Electronic authentication for students with disabilities
Digitization undoubtedly represents a key solution to the challenges of modern society: it presents the opportunity for greater flexibility in higher education learning and makes it available to all students, regardless of their disabilities or special needs, personal circumstances, geographic location, or exceptional local or global context, such as with the COVID-19 pandemic.
The identification process typically requires users to introduce information, such as their name, user ID or email address, while authentication requires them to disclose private and secret information, such as a password. In general, both non-private and private user information can be compromised in a variety of ways, which may potentially jeopardize user identification and authentication. Trust is a fundamental precondition for the success of any new form of technology, particularly in the field of education, and trust in relation to electronic authentication appears to be a complex issue.
To what extent do students accept the sharing of personal data for e-authentication purposes? Do background variables, such as type of disability, gender, age, educational level, etc., play a part in terms of the willingness of SEND (special educational needs and disabilities) students to share personal data for e-authentication? What are the advantages and disadvantages of using e-authentication in electronic assessment according to students with special educational needs?
Crucial factors for the acceptance of the system
The responses collected by the study ruled out special educational needs or disabilities as a variable that influences a student's willingness to use an authentication system, such as TeSLA, highlighting factors such as age, gender and previous technological experience as more likely to impact their acceptance of the system. After analysing the results, the researchers identified three factors as being crucial with regard to system acceptability: familiarity with the technology on the part of the student; the additional effort required for using the system, and the degree to which students deem the technology to be intrusive.
The results of the study are of particular interest to academics and researchers working to facilitate access to online assessment for students with disabilities. As Bañeres pointed out: "The study gives us an understanding of their perceptions and therefore helps with making decisions in terms of the most suitable system for use in these cases and which authentication and authorship identification tools they are willing to use. It also gives us an insight into how they feel about sharing personal data."
It is important to consult students with special educational needs on their views regarding e-authentication in education and maintain their trust when implementing new technologies, as well as to respond to the doubts and needs of students with disabilities to prevent e-authentication from becoming a barrier to their studies.
This study supports the following Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs): 4, quality education; 9, industry innovation and infrastructure; 10, reduced inequalities.
Laamanen, M., Ladonlahti, T., Uotinen, S. et al. Acceptability of the e-authentication in higher education studies: views of students with special educational needs and disabilities. Int J Educ Technol High Educ 18, 4 (2021).
This project is supported by the European Commission (H2020-ICT-2015/H2020-ICT-2015), Number 688520.
More information about UOC’s TeSLA project
The UOC headed up the TeSLA (Adaptive Trust-based E-assessment System for Learning) European research and innovation project, which aimed to define and develop an online evaluation system (e-assessment) that authenticates student identity and verifies the authorship of learning activities (exams, exercises, etc.) in online learning environments.
The TeSLA consortium involved the cooperation of eighteen expert organizations, including eight European universities, three quality evaluation agencies (the Catalan University Quality Assurance Agency [AQU Catalunya)] in Spain, the European Association for Quality Assurance in Higher Education AISBL [ENQA] in Belgium, and the European Quality Assurance Network for Informatics Education e.V. in Germany), four international research centres (the University of Namur in Belgium, the National Institute of Astrophysics, Optics and Electronics [INAOE] in Mexico, the IDIAP Research Institute in Switzerland and Imperial College London in the United Kingdom) and three technology companies (Protos Sistemas de Information in Spain, LPLUS GmbH in Germany and Watchful in Portugal).
A team of eighty professionals and more than fourteen thousand students from around Europe participated in the TeSLA Project.
The UOC's research and innovation (R&I) contribute to solving the challenges facing the global societies of the 21st century by studying how technology and the human and social sciences interact, with a specific focus on the network society, e-learning and e-health. Over 500 researchers and 51 research groups work among the University's 7 faculties and 2 research centres: the Internet Interdisciplinary Institute (IN3) and the eHealth Center (eHC).
The United Nations 2030 Agenda's Sustainable Development Goals and open knowledge provide strategic pillars on which the UOC's teaching, research and innovation are built. More information: research.uoc.edu. #25yearsUOC
Researcher from the IN3's SOM Research Lab and UOC eLearn Center